Music: October 2005 Archives



Someone in a Newsnight editing booth has obviously been to see Michael Nyman recently because Susan Watts' piece on nanotechnology this evening was packed full of Gatacca music. Fantastic.

Beethoven Downloads

| | Comments (2)

This article (free subs. reqd.) about the BBC's Beethoven downloads really annoys me. Not the article itself, but the words and thoughts of John Whittingdale of the Culture, Media and Sport Select Committee.

It seems that the record companies are still annoyed that the BBC actually gave away some music free. These were recordings of live concerts recorded at licence payers' expense for Radio 3 by members of an orchestra that's also paid for by the licence fee. And the composer's been dead some 178 years, so there aren't any royalites due to any Beethoven copyright holder. Although rumour has it that the record companies might quite like extend copyright until 200 years after a composer's death. I mean, how else are they going to be able to turn a profit from The Beatles' back catalogue. The fact remains that I paid for this music, so why shouldn't I be allowed to have a copy?

The usual nonsense about it taking a commercial CD upwards of five years to reach 1.4m sales (the cumulative number of downloads) was spouted. Of course, if anyone did any research into the people who downloaded they'd inevitably find that the downloads reached a far wider audience than the classical CD market does. Initiatives like this actually grow the audience for classical music. I suspect that a goodly number of those who downloaded that music had never bought a classical music CD in their life.

I completely understand that the classical CD market isn't as buoyant as it once was, and that labels are having a tough time. But there are other issues at stake here. And protectionism isn't the answer.

I'd have more sympathy with the classical music labels if one of them could publish some verfiable data to show that their commercially available Beethoven catalogue suffered some kind of marked drop-off following Radio 3's Beethoven week. I mean, it surely isn't possible that more people than normal bought Beethoven CDs in the weeks following that initiative is it? It seems terribly unlikely that someone heard something and thought "I'd like to hear more Beethoven now", isn't it?

In a strange way, this actually seems to hark back to the old days of The Third Programme, when "needle time" was limited, and BBC Radio was forced to broadcast lots of live music to keep an industry alive. Now it's the other way round. The BBC helps support several orchestras that wouldn't otherwise exist. And these orchestras make recordings for a variety of record labels incidentally.

Who at the BBC told who at the record companies what they were doing and when, I don't know. But then the BBC shouldn't need to get record companies' permission to do anything; they already act as the biggest shop window for the recording industry there is.

Free Cowboy Junkies Music


Salon have a free download of a track from the latest Cowboy Junkies album available. You will have to watch an ad if you're not a subscriber.

Uncut magazine also has a track from the same new album cover-mounted this month. But not having the CD with me, I can't tell you whether it's the same track.

The album's well worth a listen.

Raiding The Twentieth Century


Since I downloaded this on Friday, it's barely been off my mp3 player if you see what I mean? (Via Boing Boing)

About this Archive

This page is a archive of entries in the Music category from October 2005.

Music: September 2005 is the previous archive.

Music: November 2005 is the next archive.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Twitter Latest


Powered by
Movable Type 5.2.2