State of the TV Nation

Over on the BBC’s Editors’ Blog, Newsnight Editor Peter Barron invites readers to post their thoughts on the current state of British television. He’s one of the organisers of the Edinburgh Television Festival and he’s planning on putting the comments on both the festival website and the walls of the conference centre (I assume they’ll be digital in some way).
Go away and read what people say – they have some quite interesting thoughts. And for completeness, I’m reproducing my thoughts here:

  • Show some respect for programme makers – stop telling me what’s on next before the programme I’m still watching has finished, and then shrinking the credits to an unreadable size whilst telling me again about what’s coming up.
  • Stop putting ever more invasive graffiti all over the screen – I’m trying to watch your programmes and don’t actually care that much about how colourful and jazzy your DOG is, or the fact that this weekend is a “Morse Weekend.”
  • Address the training shortfall. With the BBC shrinking, we’re left with media studies students wandering around with cameras a touch better than a home videocamera recording footage without caring about getting their white balances correct or worrying about whether the sound’s audible.
  • Step away from the overnights – big numbers are not the only criteria a programme should be judged by. Do not cancel a series or banish it into the wee hours if episode one under-performs. If you carry on doing this, I’ll never bother even trying to watch your programmes again. If you’re not going to invest your time in them, I’m not going to bother either.
  • Combat internet downloads by airing shows as close as possible to US release dates.
  • Stop paying silly money for US imports that are never going to be *that* successful, then leaving yourself high and dry with two of them when Sky One outbids you for season two.
  • Stop stealing shows from one another’s channels. Remember the outcry about Thames when it “stole” Dallas? It’s a free market, but how about building your own shows.
  • Don’t behave like a petulant four year old when negotiating which channels your competitor’s cable service can carry.
  • Just because BBC Four exists (for now), that doesn’t mean that BBC Two has to “dumb down” – step forward British Film Forever. This could have been a wonderful series, but is spoilt by a demeaning narration and spurious interviewees. The whole series is pitched at a level somewhere around the average Channel 4 list programme. Wasn’t it nice to see an episode of Civilisation over Stephen Fry weekend?
  • Prevent the seemingly likely severe cut backs in the budgets of such wonderful fare as Storyville, Timewatch, Horizon and other factual programming.
  • Let’s do something to combat the diminution of science on television. Guess what? Science is actually really really important.
  • Stop public service channels featuring a single reality show across upwards of a third of a year. Channel 4, you do realise that I avoid your channel during the whole of this period don’t you?
  • Explain exactly why BBC Three costs twice as much as BBC Four. Isn’t there enough television for 15-34s?


Posted

in

Tags:

Comments

4 responses to “State of the TV Nation”

  1. Bignana avatar
    Bignana

    Paxman fears for Newsnight future – why? I pay my license fee for the privilige of choosing to watch investigative journalism at its very best which questions the status quo-that means rattling cages and ensuring that we don’t all turn into a hybidised ‘norm’. That there are still those amongst us capable of original thought; and ensures that the British Broadcasting Corporation is still free of political and cultural bias to report the truth – someone needs to! Come on BBC! Stop messing about and have the courage of your (and our!) convictions! Truth is never comfortable, nor is it the place of those that do not go where angels fear to tread!

  2. Bruce Daley avatar
    Bruce Daley

    Ok Let Paxman delve into 9/11 alway`s had respect for his style of getting to the fact`s, but I feel the bbc has now lost credibility and Paxman should find work else where, as he would not be allowed to do what he can do..and that is getting the story and asking the right question`s to all and sunder, including the fire Fighter`s at 9/11…etc. New`s Night is a excellent programme but I can see it being removed, as it is upsetting to many bbc and cnn people, and of course the will control what is aired…what a crying shame on the most respected tv new`s channel in the world…or should say was !!!

  3. Brian Turner avatar

    Most businesses have to learn to work lean and efficiently. Why is there a problem when public bodies have to do so?

  4. Monkey_cone avatar
    Monkey_cone

    With all the budget cuts the bbc are shooting themselves in the foot. Yet again the BBC have had to apologise for misrepresenting the position regarding the devolution vote in Scotland, where they stated that independance was not supported in the vote. Unfortunately if they looked into it they would have realised that this was not actually a question on the ballot. It seems strange to think that if the article was from Scotland then the person would have known that. With the cuts in local offices a more centerised news feed is being put out, surely there should still be room for local journalism.
    The cuts are leading to poor journalism poor facts and in some cases this is now being held up as a reason for independance. Mon BBC I supported you in your struggle against the government get in there get it right and stop making mistakes.